This page is for
customers who have taken the time to write us, with comments or information we
think should be shared.
3/21/04
Comment From: JJ
I want to comment on the "rules" you
deemed to use in the Tournament on Saturday, March 20, 2004. I find your
practices thoroughly unethical. I find it disgusting that you have a
team from Ultimate (even if they were renamed Mighty Newbies). I was a
spectator at the game between Mighty Newbies and Deliverance and can tell you
first hand that YOU WERE WRONG. The girl in question from the Newbies
knew she was hit, when the casing was found on her side she turned around and
proceeded to yell "We didn't get nothing" (A double negative for
sure, however a tell tell sign that she KNEW she was hit and that they should
not have won that round). YOUR referee then called a meeting and changed
the decision, so guess what, you were the one who was wrong. I can
guarantee you that everyone we know in the paintball community will be
informed of the happenings of Saturday's event. If you have one ounce of
humility you would not only apologize to Team Deliverance for your actions,
but you would also refund their entry fee.
Yours Cordially
JJ
Reply from Ultimate Paintball
JJ:
Thanks for taking the time to write us. We're
sorry you didn't enjoy the tournament.
Ted and I started this field about two years
ago with the goal of having a place where families could bring the kids to play
without being embarrassed or insulted by other players OR the sport of paintball
in general. We don't do a lot of tournaments, or have big prizes because we
don't want to attract the hard core players (who tend to be more aggressive,
etc) that would intimidate the less experienced /younger/church/family groups we
want at our field. We don't put up with foul language and abusive behavior on or
around the field; we emphasize SAFETY above all, as well as good sportsmanship
and fair play.
We have our own team (Team Ultimate) who
finished 3rd nationally last year in the PSP Rookie 5 Man Division. This year,
they are competing in PSP's DIV 2 X-Ball. These boys, with Ted's coaching, have
excelled in the sport while playing in many different tournaments. The boys know
what it takes to be a good referee (they are qualified enough to have reffed at
the PSP Mardi Gras tournament in February 2004) and know the frustration of
receiving a bad (or biased) call.
27 teams played in our Newbie tournament on
3/20/2004. Many of the players there were REGULAR customers. Some players have
practiced a LOT at our field; but, did not have tournament experience. I'm sure
there were a few teams that were overqualified (i.e. had some tournament
experience) but entered and played anyway (I've had a couple of complaints about
that, too). NONE of the teams were sponsored by us, and as far as we could
determine, none of the teams had tournament experience.
You did not indicate the paintball experience,
or the tournament experience, that you or team "Deliverance" have
(although, I would guess that you are related to the Deliverance team member of
the same last name). The Naughty Newbies practiced ONCE together at our field,
that's it; the Naughty Newbies team included
- Lydia (12) has played some at our field
- Abby (14) plays at our field and practices
with Team Ultimate
- Cindy (mother of twin 15 yr olds that do
play at our field) who played 4 times previous,
- Jamie (23) who's played 3 times
- John (18) who's played paintball 6-7 times
During the game between Deliverance and Naughty
Newbies, John eliminated 4 of the Deliverance players in the first minute or so,
before he himself was bunkered. The game concluded when Abby eliminated the last
Deliverance player and hung the flag. When the ref (Abby's brother Dave on Team
Ultimate) did the final paint check, Abby did indeed have paint on her pod pack
and Dave proceeded to call her out (at this point, Abby made the "We didn't
get nothing" comment you referred to). But the other refs (including the
Head Ref) double checked it and confirmed that 1) there was NO shell on the
pack, 2) there was MORE paint in one spot than could possibly come from 1 or 2
paintballs, 3) the paint was aligned vertically along a protruding seam on the
right side of her pack.
As the refs reviewed the game AND inspected the
last bunker Abby played from, it was evident that 1) the right side of her pack
was never visible to Deliverance (because most of the team was eliminated early
in the game) while she played out of the LEFT side of the bunker, and 2) there
was a big "wipe" missing from the paint on the bunker that aligned
with the pack when Abby would be tight against the bunker. Therefore, the Head
Ref on the field called her clean and awarded the flag pull and hang to Naughty
Newbies.
The presence of paint on a player doesn't
always indicate a hit. There is always paint on and around the bunkers that can
get on a player. It is the ref's DUTY to make the best call he can make. It is
the Head Ref's right and responsibility to make a final judgement when ANY call
is questioned (whether by a player, spectator, or another ref). It's not easy,
sometimes refs make the wrong call, sometimes they even have to call two
opposing players out because they can't determine who was shot first. BUT, in
this case our refs made the right call. We had other spectators (who observed
the game and ensuing commotion) who thought the refs made a good call, and
commended them for taking the time to make the right call.
There are winners and losers in all competitive
sports; but, Deliverance gave up their chance to be winners when they got mad
and left. Their next game was a BYE (an automatic 85 points), and their final
game was against team Chaos. If Deliverance had scored 60 points they would have
made the cut-off of 8th going into the Semi-finals; 100 points would have made
them 3rd!
Deliverance behaved poorly, wrongly accused the
refs of bias, then quit the tournament. They cannot have a refund for quitting,
and it is Deliverance that should make an apology.
Finally, I'll save you some time and post this
letter on our web site. I think it's a valuable lesson for all the young players
who come out to our field to know that
1) no matter how hard you try you can't please
everyone,
2) things don't always go the way you'd like,
3) sometimes they do,
4) you have to finish to win
You and Deliverance are still welcome to come
play at our fields, and we will try to help you have a good paintball
experience. Thanks again for taking the time to write us.
Ultimate Paintball
Back to Top
|